I thought M:I 6 set a new standard for the franchise. And then I went to M:I 7 today and I think it has a real argument for being even better. Realizing full well that it was a part one of two and that I wasn’t getting a traditional movie ending, I was caught off-guard that a 2:45 movie was already over. Truly flew by.
Glad this thread talked me into broadening my horizons and giving the rest of the M:I franchise a shot after M:I 2 just left me rolling my eyes.
I’m having a really hard time coming up with truly bad movies that won best picture, but plenty of times where the upset isn’t what movie won but what movie lost. Was Crash really that bad? Maybe, but the bigger upset is that if not for that movie, Brokeback Mountain probably would have won Best Picture.
There were four times everyone will agree the Academy had a difficult but not impossible decision and made the wrong call.
1965 - Dr. Strangelove loses to My Fair Lady
1969 - 2001 loses to Oliver!
1973 - A Clockwork Orange loses to The French Connection
1976 - Barry Lyndon loses to One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
King Richard was pretty good. The whole Smith is insane thing made it hard to love as was the odd idea to make a movie about two of the greatest female athletes of all time by focusing on their dad.
There are any number of consensus classics that underwhelmed me, but A Clockwork Orange is the only one I can think of where I actively hated it. Can’t say I’m mad that it failed to ship Best Picture.
But I mean…I can do super dark. Granted that with some of them I won’t rewatch (Requiem for a Dream is always my go-to example for this), but I have great appreciation for my one watch. I don’t demand a bunch of happy horseshit. A Clockwork Orange just struck me as an edgelord pretending to do something deep.
I concede that there was probably stuff in there that sailed over my head, but I only concede that because I’m a remarkably dim movie-watcher and it’s true that lots of movies include stuff that I obliviously whiff on. Anyway, I’m more willing to just potentially be wrong about that movie than I am to sit through it again.
Only Kubrick I’ve seen is The Shining and Full Metal Jacket. I don’t really seek out old movies now, if I didn’t see it during my childhood then I probably never will.