Lemon meringue vs milkbar is a brutal round 1 matchup, those are both top 4 for me
If you want to make a really easy, no bake chocolate cream pie-like dessert, there’s this stuff called Dream Whip, usually located near the pudding mixes at the grocery store. I don’t know if it still does - I haven’t made it in a while - but it had a recipe on the back for a chocolate pie. It basically amounts to mixing the Dream Whip with chocolate pudding and pouring it into a pre-made crust like graham cracker or Oreo. Then you just let it set in the fridge.
It’s great. Basically a light, fluffy pudding pie. I used to make it a lot to bring to potlucks. The longer you let it sit in the fridge, the easier it is to cut and serve.
2 Likes
Man fuck all yall
1 Like
I’ve made that before. It is really good.
1 Like
You spelled Chicago wrong
I had to vote to see results. I really don’t care. I would have made it public with a pie chart, but that’s not an option.
1 Like
something just dawned on me and i’m really mad at myself for fighting for cheesecake as a pie instead of pizza as a pie. fucking devastated tbh a nice round cheese & pep would be dominating this rn
4 Likes
You’d be stuck with some dessert pizza abomination, no savory pies…
1 Like
This would just lead us to the ultimate winner, breakfast pizza.
9 Likes
Well except for one of the rules in the OP…
But this thing kicks ass:
Godfather’s streusel dessert pizza.
If someone else wants to do a savory pie tourney, go for it.
2 Likes
What about Pizza Hawaii?
2 Likes
It ultimately pulled 59%. That’s…not a great sign.
Sweet 16!
- Apple
- Blackberry
0
voters
- Mississippi Mud
- Strawberry rhubarb
0
voters
- Cherry
- Coconut cream
0
voters
- Banana Cream
- Pecan
0
voters
- Pumpkin
- Cheesecake
0
voters
I, too, am not a rhubarb guy. Not so much the taste, but I don’t like the texture. 
- Lemon meringue
- Key lime
0
voters