Metallica Tournament

No Remorse is by a mile the third-best track on the album though. After those top three and personally Hit The Lights as well, I can do without the rest of the album. I’ll take Escape and Fight Fire With Fire over dreck like Metal Militia.

RTL has better singing, better production, better and more complex songs. It started to reveal Metallica as better than other thrash bands of the era. I don’t love Call of Ktulu or anything but I’ll happily take it over the rest of KEA after the 4 songs I listed. There’s more to it.

1 Like

I think the arguments over those albums reveal that while Metallica’s catalog is deep, they also don’t have that many albums that are solid start to finish. That’s what makes MOP so amazing. I don’t like Leper Messiah much but as far as I’m concerned every other song on the album is a classic. The Black album was also consistent if you like the style of it, not too many stinkers on that (looking at you though, Holier Than Thou).

This is about a 20 min vid of this guy who is into music and music production pulling a song apart and talking about how the song is constructed and produced. In this case he’s doing Master of Puppets. He’s a charismatic, enthusiastic kind of guy, it’s a fun watch imo. He’s also done Enter Sandman.

1 Like

group 4 is closed, last group, 3, open for a couple more days

1 Like

Every group is the group of death.

1 Like

I often think that bands/music artists hang on too long, and in doing so ruin their legacy. Metallica should have been done when Jason Newsted left. In the late 90s there was a moment that they were essentially the biggest thing in music, which is absurd for a metal band. They had a 4 year run with Load, Reload, Garage Inc and S&M that should have been a cap to their careers.

Think how they’d be remembered if they walked away in 2001. Instead we’ve watched 20 years of aging/fading rock stars.

meh i think their legacy is intact, edit: it should be considered a plus that they continue to make music. Like the rolling stones, although i dunno how hot of a take that is.

1 Like

Fair enough. I just think of all their post-Newsted music as junk.

group III is closed, sad for no leaf clover but Unforgiven II won so I’ll take it. See if i can get up a group from round of 32 in a bit.

1 Like

Here we go, Group 1 portion of 2nd Round:

I fixed the bracket, let me know if you see an issue but i believe we are good. I hope…I flip flopped the bottom left quadrant but it doesn’t change anything t so i didnt fix it.

Some interesting matchups i think with different style songs and “classic metallica”/later metallica.

All these songs rock though, Metallica is just too good.

  • Enter Sandman
  • The Memory Remains
0 voters
  • I Disappear
  • Seek and Destroy
0 voters
  • The Unforgiven
  • The Four Horseman
0 voters
  • Sad But True
  • Whiplash
0 voters

Oh man, Unforgiven vs Four Horsemen. Gonna have to think about that one. Hard to compare tracks which are at either end of the Metallica catalog stylistically.

3 Likes

Man that riff drop at 2:35 tho.

  • I like The Memory Remains, but come on.
  • Seek and Destroy easily.
  • And the two Kill Em All tracks over the two Black Album tracks. I just like the thrashier sound.
1 Like

Yeah that was a close one for me. I ended up going with Unforgiven because while Four Horseman is great to listen to, Unforgiven has more “moments” for me.

1 Like

People voting against Unforgiven?

image

1 Like

With the four horsemen ride, or choose your fate and die!

1 Like

GOAT going down in the 2nd round would be pretty disappointing for this tournament.

1 Like

Into that melodic broken chord riff at 3:27, then the solo to follow, The Four Horsemen owns

when Hammett actually had something interesting to say in his soloing

1 Like

that Unforgiven chorus is nice, though, of course

good song whhhoad I’ve known at 3:07 Hetfield!