Let's fight about artists with one clear *best* song

I gave my own is that not the way too go?

The Boxer by David Simon.

The Blair witch project by Eduardo Sanchez & Daniel Myrick.

As I understand the Q better now. :sweat_smile:

The Wire by Paul Simon

2 Likes

Boston - More Than a Feeling

The first 2 Boston albums are both nearly perfect but this is their iconic song.

Boogie Nights is pretty good but Magnolia is PTA’s masterpiece. I am aware that I’m the only person who thinks this. I also really liked Hard Eight.

1 Like

I’d say hardeight was my Fav gambling movie with it being so dark and of the times.

I dunno what suzzer wants exactly. I could make a case against Bohemian Rhapsody as a huge Queen fan: try listening to it a million times for the next 25 years; the novelty of it wears off pretty quickly. It’s a long unstructured song that kind of drags on. Sometimes I wonder if it seems better than it is because it breaks up the monotony of similar-tempo, similar-format (ABABCB) songs in playlists. Like just within the Queen discography itself I don’t even think it’s the best song of that style and would take March of the Black Queen over it any day but how many people have heard that?

1 Like

Salieri gets slighted again

1 Like

Probably the 1st time I listened to that Queen song. :+1:

1 Like

My utter hatred for Magnolia is enough to keep me from watching more PTA movies out of fear they’ll be similar.

Yeah for Queen I don’t get a clear #1 signal. We will rock you/we are the champions is pretty awesome.

My personal favorite is Another One Bites the Dust - but I wouldn’t hold it up a clear #1. I love the guitar melody starting about 2:38:

3 Likes

They also had Freeze Frame. So I’ll allow it. And completely agree about Centerfold.

Suzzane by Leonard Cohen

/thread :grinning:

No - I specifically said they must have at least 4-5 other hits. No Dexy’s Midnight Runners.

This one’s a pretty good example. I like Foreplay/Long Time when played together. But More than a Feeling is the instant classic.

Speaking of instant classics - another one that is so clear it might even be trivial - Oasis - Wonderwall.

2 Likes

Say say two thousand zero zero party over, oops, out of time
So tonight I’m gonna party like it’s Nineteen Ninety-Nine

I’ll party like it’s 1999 When Doves Cry

1 Like

The last time anybody cared about that song was 1989.

If Prince has a clear #1 it’s When Doves Cry. Your brain partied too hard in 1999.

2 Likes

If anyone says either Radiohead - Creep or R.E.M.- Losing My Religion we’re going to have a fight on our hands. I agree that Queen - Bohemian Rhapsody is a no brainer though.

As for actual contributions to this thread, I love all 3 of these bands but there’s little doubt that they each have a single stand-out pinnacle:
Arctic Monkeys - I Bet You Look Good On The Dancefloor
Arcade Fire - Rebellion (Lies)
Pink Floyd - Shine On You Crazy Diamond