Also, why are savory pies out? There are so many great savory pies, like Shepperd’s pie; and if you asked yourself:
What we have so far:
Apple
Cherry
Peach
Pecan
Pumpkin
Lemon meringue
Mince
Chess
Chocolate peanut butter
Cheesecake
Strawberry rhubarb
Coconut creme
Key lime
French silk (chocolate creme}
Momofuku Milk Bar
Sweet Potato
Oreo
Mississippi Mud
Rhubarb
Blueberry
That’s 20. Let’s try to get to 32 to fill up a bracket. If it’s tight, I might reverse course on the cake pies.
Huckleberry pie
Because I said so!
I think savory pies are a separate food category. Start a thread for them if you want.
2 Likes
Sour cream raisin pie:
Kentucky Derby pie
Well? How was it?
It was a long time ago but IIRC it was not unlike pumpkin pie. It was fine.
Probably a similar recipe to sweet potato pie, but with beans.
Fuck AI.
This is a pie with cheesecake as it’s filling.
1 Like
For a lesser-known sleeper pick from the Mid-Atlantic region, I nominate Shoo-Fly pie.
Super sweet, but molasses has enough toasty complexity that it doesn’t taste like straight sugar
1 Like
I’m in ONLY if we have all white people pies with their own entries and then all other pies rolled into a single “ethnic pie” catch-all entry.
2 Likes
I am absolutely never going to shut the fuck up about this btw
4 Likes
I was thinking about this pie, but I couldn’t remember the name.
- Pumpkin
- Coconut Cream
- Cherry
- Cheesecake with cherries on top
where my chicken pot pie crew
2 Likes
Caramel Pie
