GOAT Pie Tourney

Coconut Cream? OK Gilligan…

3 Likes

Talking to my aunt, I brought up this thread and told her the finals were apple and French silk.

“What’s French silk?”

I hope you slapped her.

2 Likes

I told her its chocolate pudding in a pie crust with whipped cream on top.

1 Like

A wild Sean Connery appears.

1 Like

image

I think I put French silk 12th or 13th out of 16.

1 Like

Sweet potato? What in the flying fuck?! I like sweet potato just fine - w some savory dish. But for dessert even apple beats that.
I stopped voting after about 6. The rest are canceled imo.

1 Like

One of our Thanksgiving guests brought a pumpkin pie AND a French silk pie.

3 Likes

Decently solid way of hedging.
[Steve van Zandt nodding gif]

Well played I say.

1 Like

I had a cold apple crisp pie for dessert today and damn was it satisfying.

1 Like

Looks like they’re getting an invitation for next year!

1 Like

Make people vote on their favorite.

1 Like

“Jim, do you want rhubarb or sweet potato?”

Me:

2 Likes

Tell me you’ve never had sweet potato pie without telling me you’ve never had sweet potato pie.

Think pumpkin, but better.

Which one was gone faster?

I’ll allow it, but that’s basically telling you directly.

Yeah both are vegetables and belong to the bottom of any pie ranking.

1 Like

Funnily enough, nobody ate either one. It was a fairly small gathering - my family of four, my daughter’s boyfriend, and my son’s friend and the boy’s mom (who is also our friend). Everyone was stuffed from dinner. I had made chocolate chip cookies with a cheesecake filling, so everyone wanted to try those first. Then we played some Drawful and my son’s friend was tired, so they went home. Then my daughter and her boyfriend went out.

We do still have the pies - I had a slice of each while watching the Packers.

1 Like