There is such a wide range on both of these things. If done well, they’re both great.
Normally what happens is people are comparing a good version of one vs a bad version of the other.
You said roasted and my brain went to baked. Roasted potatoes are great with garlic and dill weed.
Mashed potatoes w/gravy and scoop some corn on each bite, though.
Ham gravy
Seltzer has pumpkin polling +4.
5 Likes
Well, it appears that the voters have officially bungled another tournament poll as they tend to do. I will console myself by looking forward to eating some tasty pumpkin pie on Thursday.
Thanks for running, Jim.
3 Likes
Had one of these bad boys today, so good. You could throw a couple packets of Splenda in there and take this thing down imo.
Apple pie, the all-American dessert, rolled through the bracket into the finals.
The contender, French Silk, took down some blue-bloods in pumpkin and blueberry on it’s way to the final.
- Apple
- French Silk
0
voters
1 Like
OK these are both great pies but this is still America, last time I checked.
3 Likes
I am not anti-Apple pie like some ITT but out of these two, I went French silk. I wanted blueberry to win it all. I’m happy pecan and pumpkin didn’t make the finals, those are both mediocre
1 Like
1 Like
I can’t say no to chocolate.
We need a cake tourney next. I love a good sponge.
2 Likes
Two good but not great pies in the final.
1 Like
Pretty simple, you put both pies in front of me, tell me each is the best pie you can possibly get and I can only have one piece, I take French Silk. Coconut Cream is the only one that would have been tough vs. French Silk.
1 Like
jacknodding.jpg
WTF?
1 Like
My vote turned on the presumed availability of ice cream and whipped cream and would be different otherwise.
French silk can be a midnight snack eaten right out of the fridge, and is a better primer for cold-ass milk.
I would also change my vote if both options were cold.
After some self reflection, I think my favorite pie is probably boysenberry.