Honestly, I was gonna ask if we can consider cheesecake a pie until I saw beetlejuice nominate cheesecake and I just decided to go with it
Where do you live that most cheesecakes don’t have a crust?! The crust is the best and most important part of a cheese cake! In fact, a good crust is arguably the best part of any pie
Therefore, I think cheesecake can be considered a pie imho
Momofuku Milk Bar Pie (formerly known as Crack Pie, because, well, you know…)
LOL at Boston Cream Pie counting. If you think this thing is a “pie”, I’m afraid you are very confused.
Lemon Meringue Pie
Not because it’s good, but we need some fodder.
Of course, now that I say that, it will probably ship like breakfast sando.
Edit: Just saw that Lemon Meringue is in OP. Never mind, then.
Sweet Potato Pie
Oreo Pie
Coconut Cream Pie
Mississippi Mud Pie
First sentence disqualifies it.
Key lime
/thread
Was going to throw this one fosho.
Also straight rhubarb (w a bit of sugar to keep Rugby happy). Straight tart rhubarb w a very sweetened crust is elite.
But I’m sure strawberry/rhubarb will poll much better.
That’s a cake! gtfo.
This!
Don’t post any more cakes people. Start your own thread.
Cheesecake is reasonable to consider, imo. Can’t let the name fool you other wise LOL Boston Cream Pie would be in.
I still think it’s out, but it’s close. Makes a lot more sense than BCP or that German cake.
Your pony choked on a pie.
Chocolate cream pie. Preferably the one my grandma made.
Cheesecake has a crust. It’s good here.
Asian creampie
They sometimes have crushed graham crackers as a base but they mostly look like this:
Sometimes much thicker. A pie shouldn’t be higher than the crust unless it is has a meringue dome or something.
Chocolate cream or chocolate silk
