Capitalism vs. Socialism

11 Likes

It’s the lifeboat you don’t know you’re in.

Every capitalist system in the world is a “hybrid” system. The US today has more socialism than anyone could have imagined 100 years ago. There is no difference in kind between the US and Denmark, there are differences of emphasis and degree.

It’s not meaningful to blame capitalism for current woes.

2 Likes

No kidding. The US system is much farther to the capitalist side than the socialism side. That’s why it sucks. The European models are largely much farther to the socialism side. That’s why they suck less. I completely disagree that capitalism isn’t to blame for what is happening in the United States. The more capitalism you have the shittier the situation for the average citizen and I don’t think that is deniable really.

15 Likes

Yes that’s the best point, also would like to add that we haven’t had democracy here as it should be yet. We are still working towards what it should be and if there is a slide it’ll just be back the “old” democracy of democracy for white men which is what it’s always been up until pretty recently, less than one lifetime ago.

2 Likes

It’s ok to blame capitalism for current woes as long as.you keep in mind it can be a lot worse.

Do you think people here are saying that things can’t possibly be worse? The point is that things are bad because of the capitalism. Make an actual point that refutes that rather than this strawman you are both clinging to.

1 Like

I think things are good in part because of capitalism. For example, the phone I’m typing this on.

I’d like to see a version of this where the second panel reads, “This is socialism.”

7 Likes

I don’t want to debate this certainly with you, but having smart phones is in no way a thing that “only can happen with capitalism”, nothing is, it’s just something dumb that people say

6 Likes

If anything I would argue that the current state of capitalism hinders novel technological advances in things like phones(and most other industries). That market is controlled by a tiny number of players who re-release the same phone for a decade with minor tweaks. Then the media owned by those conglomerates puts out 100 AI pieces about how great the new IPhone 27 is. Then iron buys one for $1200 and thinks WOW CAPITALISM IS GREAT!!!

1 Like

11 Likes

Did you know that without capitalism people just stop thinking of inventions? Weird I know but it’s true!

8 Likes

Innovation!

I’d love to see the scale that you’re using for this claim.

You think the US is more socialist than capitalist?

I looked it up, 27% of US GDP goes to the govt. So 27% socialist. The highest is France at 46%.

I think socialism doesn’t mean ‘has programs for social welfare’. I think socialism means that control of the means and distribution of production falls to the collective. That is decidedly not what happens in Europe.

You’re doing the same thing that RWNJ’s say about Europe when they call Europe socialist. You just think it’s good. Neither of you seem to know what that word means.

Anyways, I’d really like to see the scale that you use to say that Europe is more socialist or whatever than the USA.

3 Likes

It’s like you’ve never thought for more than 10 minutes about the nature of economic systems.

That’s socialism!

3 Likes