Walrus Grab Bag 6 - Reveal Thread!

In 8th place (2 points)

“Sad Sad City” by Ghostland Observatory

This felt more like an electronic song which is understandable given that other bands use the sound to replace a guitar. However, this doesn’t feel like rock at all. It’s not exactly a bad song. It’s just not good and something that I wouldn’t listen to again.

4 Likes

Brutal. I love that song and band. I was close to my predictions.

Surely we’ll get to actual rock songs soon, right?

Probably me as well

I had never heard of them before, at least

Well it would have been funny if “pick a random song from the guitarless bands list” had won. But alas it came in last, as it deserved. Although I do kind of like the song.

1 Like

And to end the nodium in 7th place (3 points)

Death From Above - “Trainwreck 1979”

Okay, things step up in quality a bit starting from here in that we actually have what I consider a rock song. When I first heard the song, it sounds like the music from a Dude Perfect video. That’s not a bad thing. Those songs tend to be a bit catchy. I guess this one is a bit simple though. Sounds like something I wouldn’t mind hearing in the background of a bar or something like that.

3 Likes

This was me! Another nodium!

1 Like

I liked all 3 nodium songs. :slight_smile:

2 Likes

In 6th place (4 points)

Royal Blood - “Trouble’s Coming”

I don’t think there’s anything necessarily wrong with this song. But to me, it has a sort of droning sounds that kinda bores me a bit in the beginning. It picks it up a bit later on but not enough to be ranked higher.

1 Like

Damn, thought I would do better with this.

In 5th place (5 points)

Au Revoir Simone - “Crazy”

I kept flipping back and forth between “Trouble’s Coming” and “Crazy”. Couldn’t decide which one would be 5th. I like this song more but it’s more indie pop rather than rock. I’m still not completely comfortable with either position but this is how I will set them.

1 Like

that sound @pauwl -esque

1 Like

Yeah, this is mine. I found alot of my electronic rock bands have a guitar player and remembered Au Revoir Simone on stage in Twin Peaks with 3 keyboards.

eta: And the music video is super fun

1 Like

And this is the song picked by two people!

Meaning that it’s podium time! Guess a couple of you are gonna have to share bronze here.

Tied for 3rd (6.5 points)

Royal Blood - “Out of the Black”

To be honest, I feel that hearing this Royal Blood song probably made me dislike the other RB song a bit more than I should because this one is just so much better. Like way, way better. I mean this is the type of song I was looking for.

And it would’ve been first if two songs weren’t picked that came completely out of left field in this category. They sounded completely different from what I was expecting and that’s what took me by surprise.

2 Likes

Oh hey, I got top 2? Huzzah

2 Likes

half podiumed means my 6 podium streak continues?

2 Likes

Wait, I’m not one of the repeats AND top 2? What a day!

1 Like

You guys are gonna be so mad at my cheating here

1 Like

you were whining a lot early on for someone who about to win the whole thing

1 Like

I thought for sure others would find the band I chose

1 Like