Trans Issues In Sports/Society

Holy fuck, man. Really?!

Yes, really, I think. Unless you meant to reply to somebody else. What is the problem?

I, for one, am especially glad to see that you could take this moment and make it about how much better you are than everyone else.

Gonna go ahead and repeat what I said to Skydiver8:

It’s entirely possible you didn’t read the post I was replying to so I’ll just say, yes, I agree it would be super bad for somebody to take this moment and make it about how much better they are than everyone else.

1 Like

For the love of god can we not respond to 6ix on this forum. There is a pitbull 2p2 OOT thread that is just for responding to 6ix.

3 Likes

Agreed, we should stick to the point here, which is that if we’d all listened to Rugby in this thread 15 months ago, Rivaldo would never have posted what he posted. He TOLD us, we didn’t listen

Chuckleslovakian did the thing.

:pitbull1:

3 Likes

You can try and make this place safer, you actively choose not to.

To use an analogy.

Imagine Chris has a bunch of guys he plays football with.

One of them does a bunch of creepy insulting shit to women.

Someone calls it out. Not only does Chris not agree, he goes out of the way to point out how the complainer is shrill, hysterical etc, ridicules them for exaggerating.

Well, yeah, if that creeper sticks around and molests a woman at the club house then fuck yes Chris is responsible.

And here, again. Without a single seconds fucking pause he’s in here taking the piss, without knowing what happened.

1 Like

Edit: I originally replied engaging in argument but I’m not going to do that. This thread is from 17 months ago man. You can think whatever you like of me, I sincerely do not care.

I’ll just say that I find this idea of yours that any deviation from total agreement with you puts in me league with the worst transphobes on earth to be incredibly reactionary thinking. It’s literally “you’re with us or you’re with the terrorists”, the context is very different but the idea is the same.

1 Like

The obvious difference being if the world had more people like six it would be a much better place.

If the world had more of people like you it would only be slightly shittier. All that to say is you are probably a decent person.

2 Likes

You’re in a cult my man.

5 Likes

The cult of 6 has one member, me!

1 Like

I went back and skimmed this thread and my god there are some horrible takes. There is also blatant transphobia from a couple of posters that isn’t in the category of slight disagreement. Obviously Rivaldo was one of them. I can see why that might make a trans person uncomfortable. It is pretty simple. Trans people are under attack right now. They deserve unequivocal support rather than treating this issue as an intellectual exercise to determine exactly where the “fair” point is for excluding them in women’s sports. As I said last year that’s falling for the bait the right has laid out for you.

15 Likes

This is some weird “no true leftist” gatekeeping.

No but it probably means you’re familiar with the struggles cancer patients experience, right?

3 Likes

Well said.

As someone who has previously taken this bait on more than one occasion, I realize I need to do better.

3 Likes

I agree that there are some really bad takes, but I disagree that a topic like this should be off limits in order to show unequivocal support. There are lines being drawn in the real world–basically all of them much farther to the right than we would prefer–and I think discussing the proper placement of those lines is a fine discussion within a community at least supposedly dedicated to discussing politics.

5 Likes

Topics like this are tricky though because it kinda has to be an academic exercise, given the predominantly cis het male makeup of this board. Similarly for issues of sexism and racism. I think to have an actual discussion on these topics we need a community built on mutual respect, which we don’t really have, and we need to extend a lot of respect to folks directly impacted by these issues and should strive to make them feel safe.

Idk, it’s tricky.