Personal/Political dilemma

I have a dilemma.

I’ve just finished my Master’s in Energy from a leading Australian university. It’s all about renewables, climate change etc.

I did well.

Today I just got notice I’ve been offered a scholarship prize.

The problem.

It’s the ExxonMobil energy systems prize.

I was immediately thinking “lol. Fuck no. Get fucked” assuming it wasn’t very much.

Then I found out it’s $5000 Aussie dollars.

My wife and I aren’t earning right now because of the new baby and me starting a business. We have plenty of savings, but the money would be useful.

Mrs Rugby thinks I should take it.

I’m still pretty adamant to tell them to fuck off.

As well as ExxonMobil’s most famous fuckeries on climate change, they have a big program of funding universities to soften research and statements on climate change, and to influence students as well. This is clearly part of that.

A final option is trying to turn this into some free marketing for my business (in green energy stuff), if I only I can get some attention for telling them to fuck off.

Thoughts?

2 Likes

Take their fucking money imo. Do good things.

24 Likes

If you feel strongly enough then pass. But you could take it and subvert whatever their goal is at least relative to what someone else might do. Or if you’re a pessimist, you might be less corrupted than the next guy. Most of us have to take money from the man at some point.

1 Like

I would never work for Exxon, but I’d take their money.

10 Likes

what does scholarship prize mean? you get the money and do nothing else for them?

scholarship prize here means you get the money say thanks and run so if that’s it, there’s no real point to have some fake honor in no, I would never take your money. Also that’s 5k less money than exxon has to spend if you don’t like them. You didn’t think about that now did you. If it’s so strong against you’d feel sick about it then don’t.

Telling them to f off has to go viral to help the new business and that’s just too unlikely.

1 Like

Oh. Additional info. There’s a requirement to send a thank you note to the sponsor.

You’re not working and you have a new baby and your wife wants you to take it. Take the money.

7 Likes

And it’s taking their money. You’re not drilling for oil.

5 Likes

take the money and spend it on your family.
if not, take the money and donate it to a green cause and thank exxon for their donation.
if not, take the money and give it to me.

all 3 are acceptable options. not taking the money isn’t one.

2 Likes

Serious question.

Would you give the same advice if a doctor was given a. Grant from a tobacco company?

If it were a highly immoral action then sure, but the maybe symbolically questionable problem of playing along with Exxon’s PR while taking their money doesn’t compare to your obligation to your wife and child and not just doing what is best for them, but not making this even a point of contention because it’s not worth it.

1 Like

yes.

as long as you dont work for them and they dont get to tell you what to do with the money, i don’t see the moral issue here.

my wife is a P.I. and she will take any grant that is willing to give her money and not restrict her research. i’d def advice her to if she has any moral issues with taking money from monsanto or something.

eta - if they are making you run through hoops and like wear an exxon t-shirt while running on stage in an exxon company event i get it. doesn’t sound like the case though.

4 Likes

I got a small scholarship as an undergraduate. It turned out somewhat later there was an expectation to show up and parade at some function. I refused, mostly because I was extremely shy. I got a phone call from a person who got angry at my apparent lack of gratitude. Always a catch. But you can have chatgpt write a thank you letter, so take the money.

1 Like

If Exxon didn’t exist would some other company just take their place?

As far as the thank you note, you could just say thanks for the money.
Alternatively you could say thanks for the money, I look forward to helping build a more sustainable planet.

2 Likes

I’d take it in a heartbeat.

You can always get snarky and put some coded put downs in the thank you letter. Post it here for our amusement.

1 Like

One could make a decent argument that the ethical thing would be to -5K them.

If it doesn’t mean you have to DO something bad, wouldn’t you rather you have some of their money than they have it?

Unless there is some kind of reputational loss that exceeds that windfall, I take the cash and rub it on my proverbial titties.

I think if I told them to fuck off they would just give it to another student.

I’m surprised that everyone here is so unified. Maybe my brain works differently.

very easy choice since your wife wants the money.