Something’s Gotta Give (2003)
When aging womanizer Harry Sanborn (Jack Nicholson) and his young girlfriend, Marin (Amanda Peet), arrive at her family’s beach house in the Hamptons, they find that her mother, dramatist Erica Barry (Diane Keaton), also plans to stay for the weekend. Erica is scandalized by the relationship and Harry’s sexist ways. But when Harry has a heart attack, and a doctor (Keanu Reeves) prescribes bed rest at the Barry home, he finds himself falling for Erica – who, for once, may be out of his league.
Let’s be clear. Nancy Meyers only makes good movies. But this is probably my least favorite of her work.
So Harry (Jack Nicholson) and this much younger girl (Amanda Peet) show up at her beach house ready to finally bang.
But first, the girl’s mother (Diane Keaton) shows up. She finally agrees to let him and the daughter stay. He and the younger girl try to have sex, but Harry has a heart attack.
His doctor is played by much younger Keanu Reeves, and there’s instant chemistry between him and the mother. I mean it’s electric. The mom is supposed to be kind of restrained with the doctor and fully into Harry/Nicholson, but that’s just not what’s on screen.
When the doctor tells Harry to stay close for observation, the mom agrees to let Harry stay in an extra room at her home, and in the script, this is when Harry forgets about the daughter and he and the mom start to fall for each other.
Nicholson is hilarious. The real star is Diane Keaton, and it’s worth watching this just for her. But ugh, there is just zero chemistry between the two of them. And when he eventually fucks things up, the mom runs into Keanu Reeves and starts dating him instead. And it’s hard not to feel like the two of them should have stayed together.
Keanu is charming and dashing, and his character is so genuine and generous toward the mom. He has fallen for her and treats her great.
But of course the script is only interested in reforming Harry from his womanizing ways until he’s worthy of the mom, a woman who is his own age.
I’d seen this once before and enjoyed it for what it was. This time I watched with the film commentary by Nancy Meyers and Jack Nicholson. It was okay. Nicholson was surprisingly restrained and kind of boring. Meyers mostly shares her love for the movie and why she made certain story decisions.