Should we take our talents to this thread now? I think the most efficient way to do this is to start from what some of us in good faith think is way beyond the line, and then work our way down to gray areas. For example, I don’t see much of a point discussing whether “god please die of a heart attack” is sanctionable (gray area, low content, I don’t like to see it, but permissible) before we agree, if we agree, that “Wouldn’t it be nice if every member of group x were rounded up, hung, eviscerated, beheaded, and quartered, and also if the rarest and most painful cancers were visited upon their children” is sanctionable/bannable.
I very much doubt we can catch anything like this in a neat rule, that’s why it will be up to the judgment calls of the mods most of the time.